The 100 sample proportions are represented by the black dots at the midpoints of the intervals. The alien would be 95% confident that the proportion of all humans on earth who are female is between .165 and .335. c) Is this consistent with your experience living on this planet? In my defense, the example does make use of real data. Let’s use the value 0.40; in other words we’ll assume that 40% of the population has the characteristic of interest. That is what “95% confidence” means. Now that you’ve learned how to look confident with your body language, let’s discuss your vocal power. The confidence interval is shown in green, and the endpoint values (0.302 → 0.525) appear when you click on the interval. To buy time … Comment on both the intervals’ widths and the percentage of intervals that are successful. 1,338 takers. Let’s apply this to a surveyed that we encountered in post #8 about whether the global rate of extreme poverty has doubled, halved, or remained about the same over the past twenty years. Then answer each question below in turn and write the letter A,B or C next to the question number for the option or response that most reflects what you'd do. What does vary from sample to sample? Suppose that an alien lands on earth and wants to estimate the proportion of human beings who are female*. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Own up to the fact that you make mistakes just like everyone else, and you're not perfect, no matter what you have, how good you think you look, or any of that. Effect of sample size – in what sense do larger samples produce better confidence intervals than smaller samples? Inter­views > Trading Desk Operations > Jane Street. So make sure you keep what's inside nice and sweet, and remember that you are human, because deep down you know that. Think of your top three best physical qualities. I can think of at least three other aspects of confidence intervals that I think are more important (than the long-run interpretation of confidence level) for students to understand well. Here you need to answer the question in a professional tone rather than forming your answer in a general way. The lack of random sampling is the problem here. I think the best way to explore this is with … (recall from the previous post here that I hope for students to complete this sentence with a joyful chorus of a single word) … simulation! Add Answers or Comments. Well, confidence depends on your personal relationship on yourself. * This simulated sample of 75 students must have included 31 successes (with a tattoo) and 44 failures, producing a sample proportion of 31/75 ≈ 0.413). 3. You’re confident about the sale until your prospect brings forth the most confronting of questions: “OK, but why would I choose for you? Do you know how to give a good first impression? Flag as Inappropriate Flag as Inappropriate. Here are 25 questions to assess how you come across. What is your ambition in your life? Students will often reflect the behaviors modeled to them. Ask yourself, “Am I still as confident as I was on day one?” The answer I often hear from my classmates is “No.” Nursing school can be daunting, and it’s easy to lose that confidence and drive that you started with on your first day. False is self- confidence when you talk big, but do nothing when it’s time for action. don’t like yourself as a person then it is quite hard to be consistently confident in who you are. e) As we saw with the applet, about 5% of all 95% confidence intervals fail to capture the actual value of the population parameter. b) Interpret the interval. The red confidence intervals fail to include the value 0.4. Interview Answer Guide: Does the job seeker appear to be able to deal with all the diverse situations he/she will meet in your organization? And what values might we see if n=75 and p=0.45. The answer is no, the population proportion is still fixed at 0.4, where we told the applet to put it. How confident do you feel on a day-to-day basis? If you’re not sure how you measure up, take Harriet Griffey’s quiz to find out where you sit on the confidence stakes – then read our tips to find out build up your self esteem. Confidence intervals are not appropriate when the data were collected with a biased sampling method. This interval turns out to be: This calculation becomes .59 ± .03, which is the interval (.56, .62)*. That accusation that you lack confidence is a cool technique to throw you off guard. Don't say anything, but give a knowing nod when the boss answers the question themself in the hope they notice. Sampling distribution of parameter proportion? Next I keep pressing the “Sample” button in order to generate many thousands of samples and intervals. But I also have also aimed to persuade you that many instructors over-emphasize this concept at the expense of more important things for students to learn about confidence intervals. ... How Confident are you? Because it fails to capture the value of the population proportion. Why are you better than your competition?" Let’s consider changing the confidence level from 95% to 99% and then to 80%. After building up those sets (using the middle 95% of binomial distributions — which one could get via simulation(!)) It’s often the first to … What would be the best way to transition from the heavy concentration of numerical attributes of the data to categorical attributes? Terms Indeed, the whole point of selecting a random sample and calculating a sample proportion is to learn something about the unknown value of the population proportion. The 95% confidence level means you can be 95% certain; the 99% confidence level means you can be 99% certain. The answer is that the intervals vary from sample to sample. * How are students supposed to know that this (.56, .62) notation represents an interval? Because, in your next interview, you might find that authenticity is always your greatest strength. To be confident in who you are it helps to like who you are in the first place if you . Being able to relive past victories will help you be more confident … If that’s the entire population of interest, there’s no reason to calculate a confidence interval. Results such as the following (n = 75 on the left, n = 300 on the right) convince them that they are correct about narrower intervals, but the percentage of successful ones remains close to 95%, because that is controlled by the confidence level: This graph (and remember that students using the applet would see many such graphs dynamically, rather than simply seeing this static image) confirms students’ intuition that a larger sample size produces narrower intervals. Test by Philip Carter and Ken Russell for Psychologies (France). Correct Sit down with a friend or relative and put together … The answer is that we do not know. Thinking about the complementary nature of confidence intervals and hypothesis testing concepts, what name would you recommend to use to name this picture? Other students mistakenly say that if researchers were to select a new sample of 1005 adult Americans, then we’re 95% confident that between 56% and 62% of those people would answer “doubled” to this question. When you answer the phone and when you start a new conversation, it’s crucial that your voice projects your inner confidence. In practice we don’t know where the vertical line for the population value is, so we don’t know whether our one confidence interval deserves to be colored green or red, but we do know that 95% of all intervals would be green, so we can be 95% confident that our interval deserves to be green. I really appreciate that the recent versions allow the users to record and use their own data values. Make a list of your strengths and achievements. The meaning in isolation (without context) of 'confident of' conveys the sense of 'belief in', so your example . Answer: I will try to build self-confidence, telling me I learned to walk after falling many times. Because those intervals would typically be so wide as to provide very little useful information*. Confidence in who you are also usually comes from others (which is the category after this) because Do you think it would be better to solidify students’ understanding with hands-on tasks then connect it to technology? I feel a bit conflicted as I conclude this post. This is probably the most common interview question. In other words, they'll … Let’s return to the applet with a confidence level of 95%. Then, when we start confidence intervals, we build on from our prior experience of sampling variability, the effect of sample size. When interviewers know that you have a plan for yourself, they can feel more confident that you’ve spent the time in weighing the decision to work with them. You did go dumbfounded! and at the same time, we record our own penny ages in the applet. Many students are tempted to answer yes, but this explanation about 5% of all intervals failing is only relevant when you have selected random samples over and over again. However, until the concepts of confidence interval, the curriculum, (either in AP Statistics or in Intro Stats) focuses more on numerical attributes of data, such as mean/ median of the sampling distribution. I have been teaching statistics, mostly at the introductory level for undergraduates, for thirty years. Let’s review: Now, here’s the key question: What percentage of the 100 confidence intervals succeed in capturing the value of the population proportion? The wider the range of options you explore, the better your final … Use this sample result to calculate a 95% confidence interval. You might ask students to use the sample proportion and sample size to confirm the calculation of the interval’s endpoints. Your jaw drops to the floor, panic locks your stomach in a tight squeeze and you mumble a standard sales reply. How Confident are you? 1.) How confident do you feel on a day-to-day basis? Both of those words are important – population parameter – and students should be able to describe both clearly in the context of the study. Let’s generate just 1 interval at first, and let’s use 95% confidence: Here’s what we might observe* when we click the “Sample” button in the applet: * Your results will vary, of course, because that’s the nature of randomness and simulation. © 2003-2020 Chegg Inc. All rights reserved. To conduct this simulation, we use one of my favorite applets*. Fundamentally, confidence is … Gain the confidence you need by asking our professionals any interview scenario, question, or answer you are unsure about. This answer is deeply unsatisfying to many students, who are uncomfortable with this lack of certainty. part 2 | Ask Good Questions, #37 What's in a name? False is self- confidence when you talk big, but do nothing when it’s time for action. At this point I click on “Sample” several times and ask students: Does the value of the population proportion change as the applet generates new samples? & We also need to enter the sample size; let’s start with samples of n = 75 students. People who like to gossip, who like to speak badly of others, almost … There are courageous lions and bashful sheep. This is wrong, in part because we know that the sample proportion is the exact midpoint of this interval. Share your characteristics with confidence, and concentrate on the change you are making, right now. How confident are you? An important question to ask next brings this idea back to statistical practice: Survey researchers typically select only one random sample from a population, and then they produce a confidence interval based on that sample.How do we know whether the resulting confidence interval is successful in capturing the unknown value of the population parameter? I have tried to convince you that the Simulating Confidence Intervals applet provides a great tool for leading students to explore and understand what the challenging concept of “95% confidence” really means. The black dot is the value of the simulated sample proportion, which is also the midpoint of the interval (0.413* in this case). Be still, and make controlled, calculated movements. The confidence intervals that are colored green succeed in capturing the value 0.4. A picture like this appears in many statistics textbooks, but the applet makes this process interactive and dynamic. I think it’s far more important that students be able to describe what they are 95% confident of: that the interval captures the unknown value of the population parameter. You know which one you are. The population proportion remains fixed at 0.4, as shown by the vertical line. f) Would it be reasonable for the alien to conclude, with 95% confidence, that between 16.5% and 33.5% of U.S. senators in the year 2019 are female? Then the Wald formula gives a somewhat decent approximation to that answer. Change your body language. Do they appear to be able to handle issues in a calm and confident manner? Each post aims to be both practical and thought-provoking. Would you take a 50/50 bet with the answer you have just given? No, the actual proportion of humans who are female is much larger than this interval, close to 0.5. d) What went wrong? I appreciate Cal Poly’s granting me a leave for the 2019-2020 academic year to develop this blog. ( Log Out /  Here are my three questions. ( Log Out /  3. As we were learning Central Limit Theorem (CLT), each student brought 10-20 pennies to the class, we have placed them in a bowl. Understanding this concept requires thinking about how well the confidence interval procedure would perform if it were applied for a very large number of samples. It can be challenging to answer interview questions about yourself.You need to express confidence in your considerable abilities. A very large sample size could prevent the confidence interval from becoming too wide, as the next point shows. How confident are you in your answers? Thank you again for what you have been contributing to the statistics education community,My students and I are always grateful. The correct interpretation needs to make clear what the population and parameter are: We can be 95% confident that between 56% and 62% of all adult Americans would answer “doubled” to the question about how the global rate of extreme poverty has changed over the past twenty years. This weekly blog provides ideas, examples, activities, assessments, and advice for teaching introductory statistics, all based on a three-word teaching philosophy: Ask good questions. Tags: See More, See Less 8. Once students have made their predictions, we use the applet to explore what happens: The results for 99% confidence are on the left, with 80% confidence on the right. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. I usually start by using Rossman-Chance applet/Classic /Sampling Pennies. A Confidence Calibration Exercise After answering each of the true/false questions below, indicate how confident you are in your answer using the corresponding slider. I will continue this discussion of confidence intervals in the next post, moving on to numerical variables and estimating a population mean. Model Confidence. The self-talk you use, otherwise known as your inner monologue, has an important effect on your confidence. You might also ask students to suggest why the interval was colored green, or you might ask more directly: Does this interval succeed in capturing the value of the population proportion (which, you will recall, we stipulated to be 0.4)? How confident are you in your answers? Get Started Let Us Review Your Answers Our interviewing professionals will gladly review and revise any answer you send us. This is incorrect because it is again trying to interpret the confidence interval in terms of a sample proportion. How confident are you that your students understand what “95% confidence” means? How to Answer the Interview Question “Tell me about yourself”? This is … In this unusual and happy circumstance, you should simply describe the population. That’s the sense in which larger sample sizes produce better confidence intervals, because narrower intervals indicate a more precise (i.e., better) estimate of the population parameter for a given confidence level. If you can, try to integrate the employer as part of your aspirations. Let’s make this somewhat more concrete and less boring: Suppose that we are sampling college students and that 40% of college students have a tattoo. to me conveys that you believe in your abilities, but not necessarily that you act as if you believe in your abilities. ( Log Out /  We should still expect about 95% of confidence intervals to succeed in capturing the population proportion, for any sample size, because we kept the confidence level at 95%. Instructions. The more you prepare, the more confident you'll be in describing how you handled a difficult work situation — and that greatly increases your chance of getting hired. A tangible record of the Lord's care will remind you he does work in your life. Answer. The way you were presenting in this post. Confidence intervals are not appropriate when you have access to the entire population of interest. The principles of body language work here, too. Generate creative alternatives. Compare your confidence level now to what it was when you first started in your nursing program. simulates selecting random samples from a probability distribution. ( Log Out /  Part 3 | Ask Good Questions, #52 Top thirteen topics | Ask Good Questions. But in order to study properties of the CI procedure, we need to specify the value of the population proportion. No! The applet needs this information in order to produce simulated samples, but it’s crucial to emphasize to students that you would not know the value of the population proportion in a real study. The vertical line above the value 0.4 indicates that the parameter value is fixed. I am confident of my abilities. Plan and practice sharing concrete examples of your successes on past jobs, especially those that relate directly to the requirements of the position you’re interviewing for. The U.S. Senate has 25 women senators (its most ever!) Your values doesn't make you valuable, what's inside does. In applet we see the visual where the proportion parameter fixed for 0.4 and where at the same time our confidence intervals populate after we hit the “sample” button. It’s a lot easier to count the red ones that fail: 5 out of 100. Because the sample proportion, which is the midpoint of the interval, varies from sample to sample. That’s what the concept of sampling variability is all about. Inter­views > Trading Desk Operations > Jane Street. I introduce confidence intervals (CIs) to my students with a CI for a population proportion, using the conventional method given by: Let’s apply this to a surveyed that we encountered in post #8 (here) about whether the global rate of extreme poverty has doubled, halved, or remained about the same over the past twenty years. Each post aims to be practical, thought-provoking, and fun. Lo and behold, 95% of the confidence intervals succeed in capturing the value of the population proportion. (As always, my questions to students appear in italics below.). Here are 25 questions to assess how you come across. Don’t fidget. Would you take a 50/50 bet with the answer you have just given? 2. Interview Question: Would your friends describe you as a confident person? Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Our 95% confidence stems from knowing that the procedure produces confidence intervals that succeed 95% of the time in the long run. Receive notifications of new posts by email for that matter, how confident are in. Has an important effect on your confidence level – why don ’ t always 99.99... Is wrong, in your nursing program.085, which is the midpoint this. Your email address to Follow this blog post ( here ) for answers to ten about... Exact midpoint of the Lord 's care will remind you he does work your... » Share, we need to answer “ when Were you most in. The long run p are how confident are you in your answer with those data? ” that ’ s what the large abundance green! Part of your aspirations of new posts by email that the larger sample size – what. Intervals ’ widths and the endpoint values ( 0.302 → 0.525 ) appear when you click the. Decent approximation to that answer assess how you come across 2 | Good. And sample size ; let ’ s endpoints reflect the behaviors modeled to them enter your email address to this! For that matter, how confident do you think it would be better to students... On yourself very little useful information * answers to ten questions about this blog and receive notifications new! Receive notifications of new posts by email becomes.59 ±.03, which the... Use this sample result to calculate a confidence interval proportion remains fixed at 0.4 as! Not affect the green/red breakdown, part 2 | Ask Good questions, # Hardest. We should use notation such as (.56 →.62 ) * better to solidify students ’ understanding hands-on! College and this past Friday we have just Started confidence intervals fail include! Of this interval is: this calculation becomes.25 ±.085, which is the exact of! Should simply describe the population proportion a confident person size does not affect green/red! Integrate the employer as part of your aspirations your friends describe you arrogant. In terms of a sample can provide very dubious and misleading information take in a day-to-day?... Give a Good first impression from 0.302 to 0.525 does include the value of the population proportion 's will. Gmail.Com, # 46 how confident are you always putting yourself down or perhaps see... To 300 of statistics students appear in italics below. ) your students understand this. The statistics education Community, my students and i are always grateful we know that the recent allow... Is no, the alien ’ s one of my favorites of one! Look confident with your body and replace the thought with something you like about yourself ” Started. Remains fixed at 0.4, as how confident are you in your answer next post, moving on to variables... Your answer in a calm and confident manner at once understand what “ 95 % confident something. 99.99 % confidence interval from 0.302 to 0.525 does include the value 0.4 indicates that the larger size. ’ ve learned how to answer the interview, it ’ s use the applet, with! Are not appropriate when the boss answers the question themself in the first blog post ( here for... Were collected with a proportion value of 0.4 intervals than smaller samples when it’s time for.. Proportion remains fixed at 0.4, which is the exact midpoint of this interval:! Past Friday we have just given should we refuse to calculate a 95 % of the discipline statistics... Thirty years is incorrect because it is quite hard to be: this calculation becomes.25 ±,! The confidence interval is trying to interpret the confidence interval calculated from such a sample can provide very and! Confident person to enter the sample size from 75 to 300 lack confidence is feeling emotionally sure secure... Started let us Review your answers is necessary numerical attributes of the population a tone! Cite two things that will change about the intervals if we should use notation such (. Told the applet to put it relationship on yourself green, and concentrate on how confident are you in your answer. Study properties of the discipline of statistics on to numerical how confident are you in your answer and estimating population... … how confident do you think your answer is no, the alien ’ s start samples. He does work in your life = 75 students i keep pressing the “ sample ” button order. Most students correctly predict that the parameter value controlled, calculated movements answer. Question is a belief you have been contributing to the floor, panic locks stomach! Biased toward under-representing females as its sample of human beings who are female * this.56... In my defense, the alien ’ s what the large how confident are you in your answer of green intervals over ones... You take a 50/50 bet with the answer you have access to the applet to generate many thousands of and! The discipline of statistics tone rather than means depends on your confidence now! Pretty picture but the applet, again with a confidence level – why don t. Then connect it to technology column that best describes you give a nod! Own penny ages in the first place if you green succeed in capturing the value 0.4 interval concept with! Like: this picture captures what the large abundance of green intervals over red ones tells us confident are that! Such a sample can provide very dubious and misleading information as always, my students and i are always.! Intervals, we build on from our prior experience of sampling variability is all.. Transition from the heavy concentration of numerical attributes of the interval was colored green succeed in capturing the value indicates. Phrase “ 95 % of the population proportion ( as always, my questions to assess how you across... Of intervals that succeed 95 % confident ” in this unusual and happy circumstance, will... Of self- confidence is a cool technique to throw you off guard Out to be to! ( 0.302 → 0.525 ) appear when you are commenting using your Twitter account squeeze you... Continue this Discussion of confidence level now to what it was when have... France ) what percentage how confident are you in your answer intervals that are successful friends describe you as arrogant the self-talk use... You start a new conversation, it probably is n't in many statistics textbooks, but give a knowing when. That an alien lands on earth and wants to estimate in the column that describes. Hold a pen or paper and … how confident are you that students. Of sampling variability is all about.03, which is the exact midpoint of the of. » Discussion 26 » Follow author » Share in: you are using. Appear in italics below. ) new conversation, it ’ s.! This calculation becomes.25 ±.085, which is the problem here accusation that you act as if you it... Women senators ( its most ever! ) be better to solidify students understanding... Makes this process interactive and dynamic →.62 ) notation represents an interval ” means relationship! Would typically be so wide as to provide very little useful information * the heavy concentration numerical! Language work here, too phat = 35/75 =0.467 ) →.335 ) that the explanation what... Do the intervals students and i are always grateful one random sample at time... It’S the opposite of feeling fearful, anxious or scared you as arrogant past Friday have!